Board of Directors Terms & Definitions >
Non-Compete Agreement

Non-Compete Agreement


A non-compete agreement is a contractual agreement between a board member and the corporation, which restricts the board member's ability to compete with the corporation during and after their tenure on the board. The agreement aims to protect corporate interests by ensuring that board members do not use privileged information gained from their position to compete with the corporation or join competing companies while they serve on the board and for a specified period of time after their tenure ends. The agreement may also outline the consequences of breach, which could include legal action or financial damages.

Board of Directors Terms: Non-Compete Agreement

As a board member, you hold a position of responsibility and trust, with access to confidential information and valuable business insights. However, you also have a career and professional ambitions outside of your board role, and these may occasionally conflict with the interests of the company you serve. This is where non-compete agreements come into play, as a way to manage potential conflicts of interest and protect the company's trade secrets and competitive advantage. In this article, we will explore the nature of non-compete agreements for board members, their importance and effectiveness, and best practices for drafting and enforcing them.

Understanding Non-Compete Agreements for Board Members

A non-compete agreement is a legal document that restricts a person's ability to work for a competing business for a certain period of time after leaving their current employer. This is meant to prevent the person from sharing confidential information or using their inside knowledge and connections to benefit a rival company. Non-compete agreements are common in many industries and job roles, but they are especially relevant in the case of board members, who have privileged access to the company's strategy, finances, and trade secrets.

Non-compete agreements typically specify the scope of the restriction, including the geographic area, the duration, and the types of competing businesses that are covered. They may also include other provisions, such as non-solicitation of clients or employees, non-disparagement of the company, and the return of company property. Board members may face additional restrictions compared to regular employees, due to their elevated level of influence and insider knowledge.

The Importance of Non-Compete Agreements in the Boardroom

The importance of non-compete agreements for board members lies in their potential to prevent conflicts of interest and preserve the company's competitive advantage. If a board member were to join a rival company or start a competing business shortly after leaving their board position, they could potentially use their knowledge of the company's strengths and weaknesses, customer base, marketing strategies, and product development plans to gain an unfair advantage. This could harm the company's reputation, market share, and profitability, and undermine the trust of shareholders and stakeholders.

Furthermore, non-compete agreements can act as a deterrent for board members who may be tempted to misuse their position for personal gain. By making it clear that there are legal consequences for violating the agreement, board members are less likely to engage in conflicts of interest or unethical behavior.

Crafting an Effective Non-Compete Agreement for Board Members

Crafting an effective non-compete agreement for board members requires careful consideration of the company's specific needs, risks, and legal requirements. Some key factors to consider include:

  • The scope of the agreement: What types of businesses, geographic areas, and duration will be covered?
  • The level of restrictions: What are the specific actions or behaviors that would trigger a breach of the agreement?
  • The compensation or benefits offered in exchange for signing the agreement
  • The applicable state or federal laws regarding non-compete agreements and restrictive covenants
  • The potential legal challenges or ethical concerns that may arise from enforcing the agreement

It's also important to communicate the terms of the agreement clearly and transparently to the board member before they join the board, so they can make an informed decision about whether to accept the position. This can help avoid misunderstandings or disputes later on.

Common Provisions in Board of Directors Non-Compete Agreements

While the specific terms of non-compete agreements for board members may vary depending on the circumstances, there are some common provisions that are often included:

  • Non-solicitation of clients or customers: This prohibits the board member from contacting or doing business with any clients or customers of the company for a certain period of time after leaving the board.
  • Non-solicitation of employees: This prohibits the board member from recruiting or hiring any employees of the company for a certain period of time after leaving the board.
  • Non-disclosure of confidential information: This prohibits the board member from sharing or using any confidential or proprietary information of the company for any purpose other than serving on the board.
  • Return of company property: This requires the board member to return any company property, equipment, or documents in their possession upon leaving the board.

Enforcing Non-Compete Agreements: Legal Considerations for Boards

Enforcing non-compete agreements for board members can be more challenging than for regular employees, due to the higher level of scrutiny and potential legal challenges. To increase the chances of success, boards should:

  • Ensure that the terms of the agreement are reasonable and clearly written
  • Act quickly and decisively to prevent or address any breaches of the agreement
  • Collaborate with legal counsel to evaluate the legal implications and possible defenses of the agreement
  • Consider alternative remedies or settlement options if necessary

Alternatives to Non-Compete Agreements for Managing Director Conflicts of Interest

While non-compete agreements can be an effective tool for managing potential conflicts of interest for board members, they are not the only solution. Some alternatives to consider include:

  • Non-disclosure and confidentiality agreements: These agreements focus on preventing the disclosure or misuse of confidential information, rather than restricting the board member's future employment opportunities.
  • Recusal policies: These policies require the board member to abstain from participating in any decision or discussion that may involve a conflict of interest, and to disclose any potential conflicts beforehand.
  • Term limits or rotation policies: These policies limit the duration of a board member's tenure or require them to step down for a certain period of time before being eligible to be re-appointed, thus reducing the risk of entrenched interests and loyalty issues.

Negotiating a Non-Compete Agreement: Tips for Board Members and their Employers

When negotiating a non-compete agreement for a board member, both the board member and their employer should keep in mind the following tips:

  • Be clear and specific about the scope and duration of the restriction
  • Negotiate the compensation or benefits offered in exchange for signing the agreement
  • Understand the applicable legal framework and consider seeking legal advice if necessary
  • Consider the reputational and career risks for both parties, and strive to achieve a fair and mutually beneficial agreement

Best Practices for Drafting and Approving Non-Compete Agreements for Board Members

Best practices for drafting and approving non-compete agreements for board members include:

  • Engaging legal counsel to review the agreement and ensure compliance with applicable laws and regulations
  • Considering the unique circumstances and risks of the board position and tailoring the agreement accordingly
  • Communicating the terms of the agreement clearly and transparently to the board member before they join the board
  • Obtaining the board's approval of the agreement and documenting the process and rationale

The Role of Non-Disclosure and Confidentiality Clauses in Board Member Agreements

In addition to non-compete agreements, non-disclosure and confidentiality clauses can also play an important role in protecting a company's trade secrets and proprietary information from the potential misuse by board members. While non-disclosure agreements focus on preventing the disclosure of confidential information, confidentiality clauses can cover a broader range of information and behaviors, such as non-disparagement of the company or non-disclosure of the existence of the agreement itself. These clauses are often included in board member agreements as a supplement to non-compete agreements or as an alternative when non-compete agreements are not feasible.

In conclusion, non-compete agreements are an important tool for managing conflicts of interest and protecting a company's competitive advantage in the boardroom. However, they should be carefully crafted and enforced to balance the legitimate interests of the company with the rights and interests of the board member. By following best practices and staying up-to-date with legal developments and alternative solutions, boards can navigate this complex issue and ensure the long-term success and trust of their organization.

Start an AdvisoryCloud

Join an advisory board