Board of Directors Terms & Definitions >
Board Evaluation

Board Evaluation


Board evaluation refers to the process of assessing the performance, effectiveness, and overall functioning of a corporate board of directors. This evaluation can be conducted internally by the board members themselves or externally by an independent third party to provide an objective assessment. The purpose of board evaluation is to identify areas of strength, weakness, and areas for improvement in the board's functioning, decision-making, strategic oversight, and leadership effectiveness. The findings from a board evaluation are used to develop action plans and recommendations for enhancing the board's performance and effectiveness, resulting in improved corporate governance and ultimately better business outcomes.

Board of Directors Terms: Board Evaluation

As a crucial element of corporate governance, board evaluation is an essential practice that every board member should understand. By assessing the effectiveness of the board of directors and identifying areas for improvement, board evaluation serves as an essential tool to ensure that boards are functioning correctly and delivering value to stakeholders. This article explores the importance of board evaluation, its purpose and goals, different approaches to evaluation, and the role of external consultants in the process, among other critical aspects of this topic.

Understanding the Importance of Board Evaluation

Board evaluation is an essential practice that enables organizations to ensure that boards are performing their duties effectively. It is a comprehensive process that involves assessing board members' performance, board committees, and board composition. Board evaluation is critical for a variety of reasons. It helps to identify gaps in board performance, identify areas for improvement or establish the need for changes to the board's composition. Additionally, board evaluation provides an opportunity for boards to reflect and celebrate successes, identify areas of excellence and share good practices. By doing so, board evaluation helps to strengthen the effectiveness of the board and enhance its reputation with stakeholders.

The Purpose and Goals of Board Evaluation

The primary purpose of board evaluation is to assess how effective the board of directors is in achieving the goals set out in the organization's strategies. In general, board evaluation helps to achieve the following goals:

  1. Identify and highlight the board's strengths and weaknesses;
  2. Provide an opportunity to align the board's objectives with those of the organization;
  3. Enhance the board's effectiveness and efficiency;
  4. Improve the board's decision-making processes;
  5. Ensure that board members remain motivated and challenged;
  6. Provide a framework for ongoing board self-assessment;

Different Approaches to Board Evaluation

There are several approaches to board evaluation, and they depend on the organization's context, size, and industry. Some organizations may prefer a formal, externally facilitated evaluation, while others may opt for an informal, internal evaluation. Below are some common evaluation approaches:

  • Facilitated Evaluation: This approach involves hiring an external consultant who is specialized in evaluating boards. The consultant provides an objective and independent perspective to the board's performance and provides recommendations for improvement;
  • Self-Assessment: This approach involves board members assessing themselves through a questionnaire or interview process. Self-assessment may be conducted by the board chair or lead director or a third party, such as the corporate secretary;
  • Peer-evaluation: This approach involves board members evaluating each other's performance based on predetermined criteria. Peer-evaluation fosters discussion and generates honest feedback amongst board members;
  • 360-degree feedback: This approach provides board members' feedback from their reports, peers, customers, and other stakeholders. This approach provides a broader perspective and a comprehensive understanding of the board's effectiveness.

The Role of External Consultants in Board Evaluation

External consultants play a crucial role in board evaluation. They help boards gain an objective perspective on their performance and provide best practices and recommendations based on their expertise in evaluating boards. External experts also bring insights into the governance practices of other organizations and industries that can be useful in identifying areas for improvement. Furthermore, external consultants provide an environment of trust and encourage board members to share their opinions without judgment, which helps to promote discussions and generate honest feedback amongst board members.

Common Metrics Used in Board Evaluation

There are several metrics that organizations can use to evaluate board effectiveness. Some of the most common ones are:

  • The board's composition, including the balance of skills, experience, diversity, and independence;
  • The board's performance, including time management, meeting structure, and agendas;
  • The board's relationship with management, including transparency, responsiveness, and communication;
  • The board's involvement in key initiatives, including strategy development, risk management, and succession planning;
  • The board's focus on governance and compliance, including processes for managing conflicts of interest, ethics, and regulatory requirements;
  • The board's contribution to corporate performance, including financial performance, long-term growth, and shareholder value.

The Benefits and Challenges of Self-Evaluation

Self-evaluation can provide several benefits to organizations. Firstly, it is a cost-effective approach as it does not require an external consultant. Secondly, it enables boards to customize evaluation criteria based on the organization's context, size, and industry. Finally, self-assessment provides an opportunity for board members to reflect on their performance and identify areas of improvement. However, self-evaluation has some limitations. The lack of an external perspective may limit the board's ability to identify performance gaps, and board members may be reluctant to provide honest feedback during the process.

Best Practices for Conducting Effective Board Evaluations

Conducting an effective board evaluation requires careful planning and execution. Here are some best practices to consider:

  • Set clear evaluation objectives and criteria;
  • Create a safe and confidential environment for feedback sharing;
  • Involve all board members in the process;
  • Use a variety of evaluation methods and techniques;
  • Ensure that the evaluation process is transparent and communicated to stakeholders;
  • Use the evaluation results to identify areas for improvement and develop an action plan accordingly;
  • Commit to ongoing evaluation and review.

The Link Between Board Evaluation and Corporate Performance

Board evaluation has a significant impact on a company's performance. Effective evaluations enable boards to identify areas for improvement, ensure they are aligned with the organization's objectives and their performance is optimal. An independent evaluation can provide insights into governance best practices, aid boards to remain vigilant on risk management, and ensure good governance. Good governance in turn translates into increased shareholder value, better customer and employee satisfaction, and ultimately, better financial performance.

Case Studies: Successful Board Evaluations in Leading Companies

Several major corporations have demonstrated successful board evaluations. For example, the British-Dutch multinational corporation, Unilever, has implemented a peer-review model that facilitates discussions on individual and group performance. The approach has enabled Unilever's board to identify areas of improvement and establish best practices that have contributed to its continued global success. Similarly, The Coca-Cola Company has recently announced a new, independently led evaluation process. The process will assess the board's composition and effectiveness in overseeing management's execution of the company's strategy. These examples illustrate the importance of evaluation in enhancing governance effectiveness and driving corporate performance.


Board evaluation should be an essential component of any corporate governance framework. Boards must evaluate their effectiveness regularly and identify areas that require improvement. Given the different approaches and metrics available, boards can tailor their evaluation process to meet the organization's unique conditions and context. Board evaluation provides an opportunity for boards to grow their strengths, adapt to changing corporate governance needs, and ultimately enhance performance.

Start an AdvisoryCloud

Join an advisory board